September 24, 2026
Rags at Classic Stage Company
Andrew joined the company of Rags benefit concerts on September 28 and 29, directed by Leigh Silverman with music direction by Mary Mitchell Campbell.
Read more

August 25, 2026
The Last Five Years at Arc Stages
Andrew starred as Jamie opposite Lili Thomas as Cathy in The Last Five Years, directed by Adam Pascal. The Pleasantville engagement ran September 25 through October 4.
Read more

June 21, 2026
A conversation with BroadwayWorld
Andrew spoke with Jennifer Ashley Tepper about Giulia, his ten Broadway shows, and a season including The Queen of Versailles, High Spirits, and The Wild Party.
Read more

March 26, 2026
Giulia: The Poison Queen of Palermo
Andrew was announced as Pietro in Jennifer Nettles’ world premiere musical at PAC NYC, directed by Mary Zimmerman with choreography by Austin McCormick. Performances began June 28.
Read more

February 10, 2026
The Wild Party at Encores!
Andrew joined the company as Goldberg in The Wild Party at New York City Center, directed by Lili-Anne Brown. The production ran March 18 through 29.
Read more

February 4, 2026
High Spirits at Encores!
Andrew joined the company of High Spirits at New York City Center Encores!, alongside Katrina Lenk, Steven Pasquale, Andrea Martin, and Phillipa Soo. The production ran February 4 through 15.
Read more

November 9, 2025
The Legacy Robe for The Queen of Versailles
Andrew received Actors’ Equity’s Legacy Robe on opening night of The Queen of Versailles, his tenth Broadway show.
Read more

August 19, 2025
The Queen of Versailles on Broadway
Andrew was announced in the Broadway company starring Kristin Chenoweth and F. Murray Abraham. Previews began October 8, with opening night November 9 at the St. James Theatre.
Read more

April 10, 2025
Gypsy cast recording
The recording of Gypsy starring Audra McDonald and featuring Andrew was announced for digital release April 25, 2025. Find it on the Audio page.
Read more

February 10, 2025
We Aren’t Kids Anymore in London
Andrew was announced as a special guest for the concert celebrating Drew Gasparini’s We Aren’t Kids Anymore at the Savoy Theatre on April 28.
Read more

September 30, 2024
Gypsy on Broadway
Andrew joined the company of Gypsy starring Audra McDonald at the Majestic Theatre. Previews began November 21, 2024, ahead of the December 19 opening.
Read more

May 13, 2024
The Queen of Versailles in Boston
Andrew joined the world premiere company of Stephen Schwartz’s The Queen of Versailles at Boston’s Emerson Colonial Theatre. The pre-Broadway engagement ran July 16 through August 25, 2024.
Read more

2022
Beetlejuice returns to Broadway
Andrew joined the Broadway company of Beetlejuice at the Marquis Theatre, covering Beetlejuice, Adam, and Charles. Performances resumed April 8, 2022.
Read more

2020
Unmasked at Paper Mill Playhouse
Andrew appeared in the world premiere of Unmasked: The Music of Andrew Lloyd Webber at Paper Mill Playhouse, a concert exploring the composer’s life and work.
Read more

July 1, 2019
Beautiful: The Carole King Musical
Andrew was announced to take over as Don Kirshner in Broadway’s Beautiful beginning July 16, 2019.
Read more

2019
Alice By Heart at MCC Theater
Andrew appeared in the original Off-Broadway company of Alice By Heart, the musical by Steven Sater, Duncan Sheik, and Jessie Nelson, at MCC Theater’s Newman Mills Theater.
Read more

2018
Twelfth Night in Shakespeare in the Park
Andrew played Malvolio in Public Works’ musical adaptation of Twelfth Night, with songs by Shaina Taub, in a five-week run at the Delacorte Theater.
Read more

2017
School of Rock on Broadway
Andrew joined the adult ensemble of School of Rock on Broadway and understudied Dewey Finn.
Read more

2017
Roman Holiday in San Francisco
Andrew joined the world premiere company of Roman Holiday: The Cole Porter Musical at San Francisco’s Golden Gate Theatre. The engagement ran May 23 through June 18.
Read more

2017
Sunday in the Park with George on Broadway
Andrew appeared in the Broadway revival of Sunday in the Park with George starring Jake Gyllenhaal and Annaleigh Ashford at the newly reopened Hudson Theatre.
Read more